Middlefield Creamery Issues Voluntary Recall of Whole Chocolate Milk
March 26, 2025 by Staff Report

Old Country Creamery, of Middlefield, issued a voluntary recall today of its Whole Chocolate Milk product bottled in pint, quart and half gallon and gallon containers due to improper pasteurization.

Old Country Creamery, of Middlefield, issued a voluntary recall today of its Whole Chocolate Milk product bottled in pint, quart and half gallon and gallon containers due to improper pasteurization.

This improper pasteurization was found during a regulatory review of pasteurization records by the Ohio Department of Agriculture, according to an Ohio Department of Agriculture news release issued March 26 on behalf of the creamery, located at 16927 Tavern Road.

The affected products have expiration dates of 04/06/25 and 04/13/25 and were distributed to 15 stores within 25 miles of Middlefield.

The quality issue is isolated to the creamery’s Whole Chocolate Milk product, the release stated.

As of March 26, there have been no reports of illness involving products addressed in the recall. However, individuals exhibiting signs or symptoms of foodborne illness after consuming the affected products should contact a physician immediately.

Those who purchased this product should return it to the place of purchase to receive a refund. Consumers with questions can call 440-548-2364.